Author: Donna Fletcher Crow


PUBLISHER:  Greenbrier Book Company

PUBLISHED DATE: November 30, 2012

eISBN: 978-1-938684-23-4

GENRE: Mystery

Source: Received for an honest review

BOOK DESCRIPTION (from Amazon): 


Lord and Lady Danvers—everyone’s favorite Victorian sleuths— accept an extraordinary new challenge that combines murder, madness, and a famed 19th century murder trial that British and American lawyers still talk about today.

The case begins when several of the destitute women who took refuge at The Magdalen House—an “Asylum for Poor, Degraded Females”—die under mysterious circumstances.

The Magdalen House—located in a notorious slum of the City of York—was established by Frederick Danvers, Lord Charles’s younger brother, who shocked the family by taking Holy Orders, and then by choosing to live near his church in one of the poorest neighborhoods in England.

But the cleric’s saintly works may come to a scandalous end when news of the women’s deaths spreads. The young Danvers is in trouble and Danvers family honor is at stake.

At first, Lord Danvers is reluctant to get involved in a criminal matter that seems so sordid. But when a devastating fire ravages Norwood Park, the Danver’s ancestral home, Charles and Antonia are forced to seek temporary residence elsewhere. Freddie’s plea for assistance includes an invitation to stay at elegant Wandseley Hall. Charles reconsiders—and soon finds himself struggling to answer two overarching questions: Are the unexplained deaths the result of natural causes? Or is an insane poisoner at large in York—perhaps a madman among Charles and Antonia’s own acquaintances?

While Charles investigates, Lady Antonia is drawn into helping feed the impoverished women and children living in the asylum.

And death is closer to home than anyone suspected. Was a servant’s untimely death an accident as first believed? Or something more sinister? And who set the fire that nearly destroyed Norwood Park?

“A Tincture of Murder” is the fourth Lord Danvers Victorian True-Crime Mystery—a riveting thriller built around actual events. Along with the entire city of York, Charles and Antonia are swept into the incredible disclosures at the trial of William Dove. The legal principles that were debated during the case still affect contemporary murder trials a century and a half later.


This was Donna Fletcher Crows fourth Lord Danvers Victorian True-Crime Mystery.  I found it interesting and well written.  Ms. Crow did a lot of research and there was much detail as to how things were at the time this case took place.

I found the book invigorating which made me want to know who the murderer was and why they were doing it.  I personally was surprised by who and why they committed the crime.  Believe me it was the last person you would suspect.  You will ask yourself, what do a fire , deaths of a maid and poor women at Magdalen House,  and a soup kitchen have in common.  You will find out what at the very end of this must read book.  I know it had me wanting to read more.

Rating:  5

Heat Rating:  Sweet

Reveiwed By:  Susan Faatz